Dessert Menu

Decadent Desserts

10 person minimum per selection

Apple Cobbler
Blueberry Cobbler
Cherry Cobbler

Bread Pudding: (serves 12)
Options include:
• Apple Cinnamon
• Chocolate Chip Bourbon
•White Chocolate Raspberry

Traditional Cheesecake: (serves 16)
Topping options include:
• Blueberry
• Cherry
• Strawberry

Chocolate Truffle Torte: (serves 10-12)
Rich, dense, Dark Chocolate Fudge Cake

Crème Brûlée:
A Creamy Custard encased by a crunchy Caramel Sugar Topping

Crème Brûlée Cheesecake (serves 14-16)

Ganache Topped Cream Puffs:
Pate a Choux Puffs filled with Vanilla Pastry Cream then topped with Chocolate Ganache

Gourmet Cookies:
Baker assortment based upon flavors listed below

Gourmet Cookies and Brownie Bite Tray:
Baker’s availability of our Gourmet Cookies and Signature Brownie Bites

Gourmet Cookies, Brownie Bites, and Miniature Cupcakes:
An assortment of Chef’s Choice Gourmet Cookies, Signature Brownie Bites, and Miniature Cupcakes

Greek Pastry Tray: (serves 10)
Assortment of Walnut Baklava, Chocolate Baklava, Pecan Tarts, and Chocolate Almond Roll

Individual Fresh Fruit Tart:
Butter Crust Tarts filled with Pastry Cream topped with seasonal fresh Fruit
Also available miniature sized

Miniature Cupcakes:
Choose from flavors listed below

TC Signature Brownie Bites:
Baker availability may include Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter M&M, Raspberry, Oreo, or Mint Oreo

Brownie Tray:
May include Peanut Butter, German Chocolate, Macadamia Nut, or Caramel


10 person minimum per selection

Strawberry Shortcake:
Fresh Strawberries, Pound Cake, and Whipped Cream

Strawberry Tart:
Miniature Butter Crust Tarts with Bavarian Cream, fresh Strawberries, Apricot Glaze and Whipped Cream

TC Famous Finger Desserts:
Baker assortment may include Miniature Cheesecakes, Ganache topped Cream Puffs, Brownie Bites, or Dessert Bars

Tiramisu: (serves 14)
Espresso soaked Lady Finger Cookies topped with Italian Custard then dusted with Dark Cocoa

Assorted Dessert Bars:
May include 7-Layer, zesty Lemon, Hollywood Squares, Cheesecake Squares, White Chocolate Raspberry, White Chocolate Snickerdoodle, Peanut Butter Brownie, German Chocolate Brownie, Macadamia Brownie, Caramel Brownie, or Chef’s Specialty based on baker availability

2 dozen minimum per selection

Crispy Cannoli Shells with a Ricotta Cream Filling dipped in Chocolate Sprinkles and chopped Pistachios

Chocolate Covered Strawberries:
Fresh Strawberries dipped in choice of Milk, Dark, or White Chocolate then sprinkled with colorful edibles

GF Flourless Peanut Butter Cookies
Gluten Free

Hollywood Squares:
Peanut Butter Bars with Dark Chocolate Topping

Vegan Black Bean Brownies


Serves 6-8 people

Apple Pie
Caramel Apple Pie
Cherry Pie
Chocolate Pecan Bourbon Pie
French Silk Pie
Mixed Berry Pie
Pecan Pie
Pumpkin Pie

No Sugar Added Pies

Apple Pie
Cherry Pie
Mixed Berry Pie


Requires a 48 hour lead time

Round Cakes (8 inch double layer) (serves 12-14)
• Filled with Fresh Fruit

Sheet Cakes
¼ Sheet – serves 15
½ Sheet – serves 30
Full Sheet – serves 60

• Almond
• Half and Half (Choose 2)
• Yellow
• Chocolate
• Marble
• Red Velvet
• White

• Apricot
• Bavarian Cream
• Buttercream
• Lemon
• Raspberry
• Fresh Strawberry

• Buttercream
• Chocolate Buttercream
•Whipped Cream
• Chocolate Whipped Cream

Cassata Sheet Cakes:

Size                        Servings
1/4 Sheet              15
1/2 Sheet              30
Full Sheet             60

Custom and Specialty Cakes available, please ask for options. Other cake flavors and frostings may be available!


1 dozen minimum required per selection

Miniature Cupcakes:
Baker availability may include any of the below listed flavors

House Cupcakes:
*Refer to cake flavors above for Cake and Icing Flavor options

Specialty Filled Cupcakes:
Piña Colada, Chocolate Covered Strawberry, Margarita, Chocolate Raspberry, Lemon Drop, Banana Split, Creamsicle, Peach Cobbler, Buckeye, Pumpkin Spice, Apple Pie, and Chocolate Peppermint


Cookie Trays

Special Decorated Cut Outs
Custom Cut Out Cookies in seasonal or themed designs on a beautifully trayed display
• Iced Sugar Cut Out Cookies
• Large Iced Sugar Cut Out Cookies

Gourmet Cookie Trays
Assortment based on baker availability
• 50 Count Cookie Tray
• 100 Count Cookie Tray

Candy Chip
Chocolate Chip
Chocolate Crinkle
Dutch Chocolate Chip
German Chocolate Chip
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip
Oatmeal Raisin
Old Fashion Sugar
Peanut Butter
Peanut Butter Chip
Red Velvet


Interactive Dessert Bars

25 person minimum per selection

Candy Bar:
Includes Regular and Peanut M&Ms, Reese’s Mini Peanut Butter Cups, Buttermints, Mini Snickers Bars, Mini Twix Bars, Lollipops, and Skittles
*Includes party favor bags

Chocolate Fondue Bar:
Includes Wooden Skewers, melted Chocolate, Strawberries, Pound Cake, Oreos, Marshmallows, Nutterbutters, fresh Pineapple, and Honey Graham Crackers
Does not include rental of Fondue Pot

S’mores Bar:
Includes Table Top S’mores Stations, Wooden Skewers, Marshmallows, Hershey’s Chocolate Bars, Hershey’s Cookies & Cream Chocolate Bars, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, Heath Bars, Honey Graham Crackers, Cinnamon Graham Crackers, and Chocolate Graham Crackers

Strawberry Shortcake Bar:
Includes sliced Pound Cake, Fresh Strawberries, Chocolate Fudge Sauce, sliced Almonds, Miniature Chocolate Chips, toasted Coconut, crushed Pineapple, and fresh Whipped Cream

Design Your Own Cheesecake Station:
Includes Traditional Cheesecake, Strawberry, Blueberry, and Cherry Toppings, Crushed Nuts, Fresh Whipped Cream, Fudge and Caramel

Chef Stations

(25 person minimum per selection)
Onsite server required (3 hour minimum)

Made-To-Order Smoothie Station:
Choose up to 3 of the following options:
• Strawberry • Pineapple • Banana • Mango • Blueberry • Raspberry • Chocolate

Bananas Foster:
Bananas sautéed in Butter, Cinnamon, and Brown Sugar, flamed with Banana Liqueur and Dark Rum. Served over Vanilla Ice Cream

Old Fashioned Popsicle and Ice Cream Stands

Onsite server required (3 hour minimum)

Select up to 3 options in the category of choice:

Twin Pop Popsicle, Chocolate Ice Cream Cups, Strawberry Ice Cream Cups, Vanilla Ice Cream Cups, Life Saver Popsicle, Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwich, Premium Ice Cream Bar

M&M Ice Cream Cookie Treat, Klondike Crunch Ice Cream Bar, Ice Cream poppers, Mrs. Fields Ice Cream Cookie, Snickers Ice Cream Brownie Bar, Snickers Ice Cream Bar, Olde Mill Ice Cream Cone, King Oreo Ice Cream Bar

Portable Freezer Rental:
Ask about availability

Ice Cream Sundaes

Onsite server required (3 hour minimum)

Ice Cream Sundaes
Choice of Chocolate, Vanilla, or Strawberry Ice Cream
Includes Strawberries, Chocolate Syrup, Crushed Oreos, Sprinkles, Whipped Cream, and Maraschino Cherries
Premium Toppings: Includes Caramel Syrup, Peanut Butter Sauce, Crushed Pineapple, Crushed Peanuts, and Toasted Coconut
*Please inquire about other specialty Ice Cream flavors and toppings!

Beverage Station

Assorted Canned Beverages

Bottled Water

Iced Tea

Fresh Lemonade

Assorted Canned Beverages and Bottled Water Station

Bottled Juices

Specialty Beverages:
Options include Blueberry Lemonade, Strawberry Lemonade, Raspberry Lemonade, Raspberry Iced Tea, or Peach Iced Tea

Coffee Station:
Includes Regular and Decaf Coffee, Sugar and Sweeteners, Half N Half Creamers, Stir Sticks, and Insulated Cups

Flavored Coffee Station:
Includes Regular and Decaf Coffee, Vanilla, Hazelnut, and Caramel Flavored Syrups, Sugar and Sweeteners, Half N Half Creamers, Stir Sticks, and Insulated Cups

Tea Station
Includes Hot Water, assorted Numi Tea Packets, Sugar and Sweeteners, Honey, Lemons, Half N Half Creamers, Stir Sticks, and Insulated Cups

Back Bar Service:
Sodas, Tonic, Soda Water, Bottled Water, Juices, Fruit and Vegetable Garnishes, Ice, and Clear Plastic Cups

Ice Service 16 pound bag

Disposable Service

Includes all appropriate service ware

Styrofoam Disposable Service:
Available in Black or White

High Quality Plastic Disposable Service:
Available in Black or White

Biodegradable Disposable Service:
Light Tan

Clear Plate and Silver Plasticware Disposable Service

Terms and Conditions

  1. To place an order or request information about our catering services, please call 330.923.9964 or email us at
  2. Our Event Coordinators will discuss rental equipment needs. We can provide china, glassware, silverware, linens, chafing dishes, serving platters, decorations, floral arrangements, tables, chairs, tents and entertainment. Please ask about other rentals that are also available.
  3. Menu prices are based on food only unless otherwise stated. Totally Cooked Catering can provide professional staff for set up, guest services and clean up.
  4. Once the menu, rentals, service staff and entertainment needs are discussed, an estimate will be available. Estimates can be e-mailed or mailed upon request. All full service events require a signed contract and deposit. Our contract includes one hour of planning with an Event Coordinator; consulting beyond this time is subject to an additional fee. We require all balances to be paid in full the week of the event.
  5. All staffed events are subject to a service charge.
  6. Please consult with our Event Coordinators or Customer Service Representatives to discuss children’s menu needs.
  7. Preferred method of payment is personal check, corporate check or cash. We graciously accept Visa, MasterCard, Discover and American Express.
  8. Cancellation Policy: If event cancels within 48 hours of the event date, Totally Cooked has the discretion of applying a service charge on food and beverage and a service charge on rentals to compensate for the cancellation.